Science of Positive Discipline

Karabo Molokomme • July 7, 2023

The Science of Positive Discipline

Two women hugging each other with the words the science of positive discipline

The science of positive discipline: Setting boundaries with love and respect


If you’re a parent of a certain age, it’s possible that just the mention of the word “discipline” conjures up mental images of an angry adult holding a cane.


Thankfully, parenting - and South African schools - have moved on (Side note: yes, hitting children is a crime, and yes, that even applies if you are their parent. Don’t do it). We now know better, and so we try to do better.


But what IS discipline, if it is not shouting at small people to enforce your will and ensure compliance with your law, no matter how tyrannical or irrational?


We’ve all experienced having to share public spaces with – frankly – horrible children and wished their parents would enforce a disciplinary boundary or two, so that we might be able to have a meal at a restaurant in peace without feeling like we were on the set of a Lord of the Flies film adaptation. Respect flows both ways, after all, and adults (and meeker children) should also be able to go about their days without being bullied by unruly little monsters. 


We’d all like to raise and be surrounded by children who are considerate and polite. The difference with positive discipline is this: we’d like our children to be considerate and polite because they understand the value of those traits in a society, and because it makes them feel good about themselves, not because we demand it and they are scared of us.


In psychological parlance, following a rule without examining it is an “external locus of control” – your behaviour is modified and controlled by rules imposed from the outside. If someone has an internal locus of control, this means they regulate their emotions and behaviour themselves, according to their own set of ethical convictions. A tall order for a child, sure, but they will develop it under the right conditions.


How can parents set boundaries with love and respect?


1.  Set A Good Example


Children learn by example. If you model a behaviour, it is likely your child will copy it – whether you set a positive or a negative example. If you stick to the same rules for life as you expect your child to, you have a far higher chance they will internalise the behaviour.


2. Set Clear Boundaries


Children actually like boundaries. It may seem counterintuitive, but it is true. A child who is given a solid framework of acceptable behaviour that is consistently applied feels less need to test the boundaries – because they never change. As long as the boundaries are reasonable and motivated by love, that child can feel safe in their world.


3. Forgive Mistakes


Children’s brains are still developing, so it stands to reason that they will make mistakes and get it wrong sometimes. Forgive a mistake, knowing that you, too have made mistakes.


4. Admit When You Make Mistakes


On that note, parents are human too. There’s nothing as powerful as admitting to your mistake and asking your child for a “do-over”. You’re modelling kindness, acceptance, fallibility and forgiveness. Your child will respect you for it. 


By Margot Bertelsmann

April 25, 2025
A Lifelong Educator Mr Chris Herbst has spent 41 years in the classroom. With a Bachelor of Education from the University of the Witwatersrand, he has taught countless learners over the decades. He joined Crawford International Sandton in 1999 and currently teaches Afrikaans to students from Grade 8 to Grade 12. His role spans across five different year groups, a challenge he embraces. “I have my hands full as I navigate the excitement and challenges of teaching an additional language to five different grades,” he says. Why Teaching Still Matters For Mr Herbst, teaching is not a job. It is something he feels deeply connected to. “Teaching is my great passion and calling. The classroom is where I find my motivation and inspiration,” he shares. “When we have a really good lesson and I see our students leave having learned something new, or figured out a challenging concept, then I am motivated and inspired all over again.” These everyday moments keep him grounded in his purpose. They are the quiet victories that reaffirm his place in the classroom. Freedom to Teach with Meaning Mr Herbst values Crawford’s approach to learning, particularly the way it supports teacher agency and student-centred learning. “I love the fact that the focus is student-centred, and that as teachers we have the freedom and the responsibility to create a teaching and learning environment that works best for every learning need,” he says. He believes this flexibility allows for learning to become more meaningful. “If I identify that a particular topic or poem has piqued the interest of my class, I have the freedom to delve deeper and really explore the subject matter without being bound by rigid syllabus rules and time frames.” Connecting Language to the Real World Teaching Afrikaans in a school where it is often an additional language means finding ways to make it resonate. Mr Herbst understands that for many students, the subject may not come naturally. “For many students, learning another language may initially feel like a requirement rather than a passion,” he explains. To bridge that gap, he brings the language to life through content that students can relate to. “It’s important to integrate engaging, real-world content such as music, movies, and stories that align with the students’ interests.” These tools, he believes, help students see the language in context and build an emotional connection to it. A Teaching Legacy  Over the course of his career, Mr Herbst has taught more than one generation in the same family. It is a milestone he reflects on with pride. “I have taught students who are now parents, and I am teaching their children today. It doesn’t get better than that.” But what stands out most for him is being remembered. “By far my biggest kick is when a past student recognises me and comes over to strike up a conversation and talk about their life and work after school.”
10 Reasons why early childhood development is important, child with glasses smiling
By ADvTECH Group April 15, 2025
The 10 reasons why the first six years of a child's life are crucial when it comes to early childhood development, read all about it in this article.
Toddler putting apples in a muffin pan, one-to-one correspondence
By Ashmita Mistry April 8, 2025
Crawford schools blog article on one-to-one correspondence in early development and the importance of this developmental skill that adults take for granted.
March 28, 2025
ALUMNI SPOTLIGHT: DYLAN BIZJAK Crawford International Sandton From the classrooms of Crawford International Sandton to the forefront of aeronautical engineering in the Netherlands, Dylan Bizjak’s journey is one of ambition, resilience and innovation . Pursuing a Passion for Engineering After matriculating in 2019, Dylan initially pursued Aeronautical Engineering at Wits University. However, six months into his studies, a new opportunity emerged, one that would take him beyond South Africa’s borders. He secured a place at Inholland University of Applied Sciences in Delft, Netherlands, where he embraced the challenge of international study, even navigating his first year remotely due to the pandemic. Now a graduate with a BSc in Aeronautical Engineering (2024), Dylan has stepped into the professional world, joining Eve Reverse, a pioneering start-up dedicated to climate-positive innovation. What began as an internship in his final year evolved into a full-time role as a Research and Development Engineer, where he contributes to the creation of sustainable, carbon-negative materials. His proudest achievement? Playing a key role in the development of the Eve Dry Tile, an innovative flax fibre material designed to reduce emissions and waste in manufacturing. Achievements at Crawford International Sandton Gareth Beach Award (2019) – Recognised for bravery, dedication, self-development and outstanding achievement in swimming. Sportsman of the Year (2019) – Acknowledged for excellence in swimming, basketball and boxing.  Reflections on Crawford Dylan credits his time at Crawford for preparing him for both academic and personal success on the global stage. “Crawford’s approach equips you for university and beyond, whether in South Africa or internationally. It’s not just about academics but about becoming a well-rounded critical thinker and team player. Exposure to diverse cultures, teamwork, individuality and taking responsibility for my outcomes were invaluable lessons I carried with me.” Words of Wisdom To his younger self, Dylan would say: “Step out of your comfort zone sooner. Growth happens when you challenge yourself. Leaving home was tough, but the personal and professional growth was worth every stumble along the way.” Dylan’s story is a testament to courage, hard work and the power of embracing the unknown. From South Africa to the Netherlands, he is proving that the sky isn’t the limit, it is just the beginning.
Career guidance for grade 9: Student resting against a whiteboard with books
By ADvTECH Group March 19, 2025
Let’s try and make sense of career guidance by giving you some information on how to choose your Grade 10 to 12 subjects. Read on to find some helpful pointers.
A young boy in a plaid shirt is giving a thumbs up.
March 19, 2025
Empower yourself as a parent by learning how to determine your child's personality type. Read more at Crawford International.
By Neo Moshoeu February 27, 2025
Explore how hands-on activities and physical engagement benefit kinesthetic learners, and discover teaching strategies that harness movement to boost comprehension and retention.
February 21, 2025
Learn how warm demanders—teachers who combine firm expectations with genuine care—can foster positive student-teacher relationships, boost academic achievement, and strengthen learners’ resilience in the classroom.
February 14, 2025
Discover how digital literacy shapes modern classrooms by fostering critical thinking, enhancing collaboration, and preparing students for success in our rapidly evolving world.
February 7, 2025
Discover essential insights and practical tips to help you navigate your child’s first year at school, from enrollment steps to building a positive learning environment.
Show More